Throwing Strategies in MLB The Show 24: From Buttons to Analog, and the Auto Throwing Safety Net | GAME3A
X

Throwing Strategies in MLB The Show 24: From Buttons to Analog, and the Auto Throwing Safety Net

In the world of MLB The Show 24, mastering the art of defense is just as crucial as your batting skills. It's all about making split-second decisions ...

Josh West Mar 20, 2024
Throwing Strategies in MLB The Show 24: From Buttons to Analog, and the Auto Throwing Safety Net


In the world of MLB The Show 24, mastering the art of defense is just as crucial as your batting skills. It's all about making split-second decisions and knowing where to throw the ball. With different throwing settings to choose from, players must navigate the strengths and weaknesses of each mode. So, tighten your grip on that virtual baseball, because we're about to explore the thrilling world of throwing strategies in MLB The Show 24!

1: Button Accuracy Throwing - "Landing the Green, Avoiding the Red"

Button accuracy throwing may seem daunting at first, like trying to juggle flaming baseballs. It's not for the faint of heart, or those who still struggle with the game's mechanics. This mode tests your reaction time in two critical areas: selecting the correct base and landing the dial in the green.

Every pick-up and throw becomes a nail-biting moment. If you miss the green zone, the ball might dive into the dirt, leaving the basemen desperately diving for cover. And if you aim for the red, well, let's just say your throw is headed for an impromptu trip to the outfield. Oops!

2: Buttons Mode - "Decisions, Decisions, and No Ticker Box"

Buttons mode comes to the rescue, relieving players of the pressure to make pinpoint throws. No more worrying about landing the ticker in the right spot; instead, focus on selecting the correct base to hurl that baseball. It's a mode that grants peace of mind to those who struggle with decision-making and reaction time.

But beware! This mode relies heavily on your player's stats, like arm strength and accuracy. Sadly, not everyone can channel their inner Derek Jeter in MLB The Show 24. However, the chances of flubbing a throw are still slimmer than with the Button Accuracy setting. So, embrace your strengths and let the buttons guide your way!

3: Analog Throwing - "Swipe and Succeed, or Flick and Fail"

For a different flavor of excitement, players can opt for the right analog throwing method. Gone are the worries of timing your throw's power; instead, you'll rely on the analog system and aim it towards the base your runner is sprinting for. Double plays suddenly feel smoother, as you swiftly swipe the analog in succession.

But hold your horses! There's a catch to this mode—literally. The analog's accuracy can be a slippery slope. A slight miscalculation in the throw's direction might have you tossing the ball to the wrong base or, worse, far away from the play altogether. If you're dreaming of becoming an exceptional infielder in MLB The Show 24, you might want to think twice before embracing this mode. Routine double plays can quickly become elusive dreams.

4: Auto Throwing - "Sit Back, Relax, and Let the AI Shine"

Ah, auto throwing—the savior of those seeking the easiest difficulty in MLB The Show 24. In this mode, the CPU's AI takes the reins, determining the best possible outcome for your throws. As soon as the ball is hit, you can sit back, catch up to the ball, and let the game's AI work its magic. It even considers your thrower's arm accuracy and strength, leaving a little room for error.

This mode is perfect for newcomers to MLB The Show 24 or those who find defense a challenge to master. There's no shame in letting the Auto Throwing mode take the wheel and lend a helping hand. And if it means racking up some extra wins in the Road to the Show mode, well, using any available assistance is never a bad option.


In the thrilling world of MLB The Show 24, defense is a game-changer. Choosing the right throwing strategy can be the difference between a jaw-dropping double play or an embarrassing blunder. Whether you thrive in the high-pressure zone of button accuracy, find solace in the simplicity of buttons mode, master the analog's artistry, or let the AI do the heavy lifting, there's a throwing mode for everyone.

So, grab your virtual glove, step onto that digital field, and make your throws with confidence. Remember, in MLB The Show 24, the right decision and a well-placed throw can turn you into a defensive legend, while a misguided toss might just have you chasing balls in the outfield. Play smart, play skillfully, and let your throwing prowess shine in the never-ending battle of America's favorite pastime!